Wireless Extenders V.S. Access Points

Wireless Extenders V.S. Access Points

Home Tech Installation Consultation | Book a Free Assessment
Sherrod Scott

Owner Sandman HD

Knowledge. Trust. Tenacity.

Today’s wireless internet routers unlike older models are rather fast and increasingly more reliable. Not only can they broadcast signal over large homes or open office space, they don’t lose speed over distance rapidly as earlier models. Though fast and reliable, for the most part, certain instances may call for more robust wireless solutions like Wireless Extenders Or Access Points.

Our need for more internet speed keeps growing, “neck-to-neck” with our yearning for more convenience. By convenience, I mean without the clutter of wires forcing us to be stationary.

Components Of A Basic Network:

• Modem

• Gateway/ Router

• Switch

• Wireless Access Point

The modem is the liaison between your Local Area Network (LAN: the network in your facility or home) and your Wide Area Network (WAN: the provider’s network outside your home, delivered through utility poles, underground infrastructure, fiber optic cable, or cellular networks). It is what allows access to the internet.

The router/gateway is the “Postman” and “Traffic Cop” of the system, it assigns addresses to connected equipment and directs the traffic between your network and the internet.

The basic function of a network switch is to expand the capability of the router which allows for more connectivity. A switch typically has more Ethernet ports than a router, some switches have router-like functions and can manage traffic, they’re called managed switches.

A wireless access point allows devices such as phones, tablets, laptops, cameras, and smart home equipment to connect to the network without a physical connection.

The wireless router you receive from your ISP (internet service provider) is all of these elements in one package, in more robust networks these elements are a-la-carte. As a network environment is scaled up and expanded these elements begin to “break apart” to achieve desired network coverage and usability.

The main options to enhance a wireless (Wi-Fi) signal in a home or office are:

• Wireless Extenders 

• Access Points (AP)

Differences between Wi-Fi Extenders and APs

While Wi-Fi extenders, no doubt, can address your wireless “dead zones”, they have rather limited capacity. Because extenders depend on a strong wireless signal input in order to attain desired outcome, placement is key. Access points, however, are hardwired and can be placed ANYWHERE accessible by Cat5e or Cat6 wire typically.

Extender Pros:

• Very cost efficient 

• Easy to install/ setup by consumer

• Readily available in local big box stores

Extender Cons:

• Historically each extender is its own network

• Not very capable in terms of coverage area

• Not very robust in terms of user interface

• Placement is very sensitive to performance.

• Typically limited mesh capabilities

Access Point Pros:

• Very Capable in terms of coverage

• Manageable controls of signal strength 

• Can be placed anywhere

• Longer life span

• Can create a mesh network 

• Is expandable as environments grow

Access Point Cons:

• Higher initial cost

• Likely needs professional installation

• Needs to be hardwired for best results

• Can be complex and requires training.

A Wi-Fi extender can be a cost-effective solution for small coverage gaps, while wireless access points are generally better suited for larger homes and commercial environments.

If you’re experiencing weak Wi-Fi, dead zones, or inconsistent wireless performance, start by identifying the size of the coverage area and the number of connected devices. Smaller problems can often be solved with a Wi-Fi extender (also called Wi-Fi boosters), while access points improve coverage in larger homes and commercial spaces.

The best way to find the solution that’s right for you is to consult a professional, if you’re in the Philadelphia, New Jersey Delaware tri-state area, we can certainly help here.